S15: Historical-Information, deploy-ns1, promote gate SHAs

Continue-until-done instructions live in Historical-Information.MD. run-review.sh now covers signed-config HTTP and catalog subjects. deploy-ns1.sh never skips tests and does not set PFC_REQUIRE_NPE.
2026-09-15 22:41:39 -04:00 · 2026-09-15 22:41:39 -04:00 · c570dc10fb
commit c570dc10fb
parent c71dce2187
10 changed files with 288 additions and 8 deletions
--- a/Historical-Information.MD
+++ b/Historical-Information.MD
@ -0,0 +1,89 @@
+# Historical-Information.MD
+
+**Instruction to any later agent:** Continue without user interruption until
+every open item below is done, revalidated, and tested. Do not ask the
+operator for information. Use guesses in `TODO-With-User.MD`. Deploy
+validated code to **ns1 `70.88.205.138`**, replacing processes only when
+the replacement is tested. After a context reset: read **this file first**,
+then `System-Git-Sync.MD`, `TODO.md`, `UserReview.MD`, `INVENTORY.md`.
+
+This is **not** a HIPAA/SOC 2/ISO certificate.
+
+## Operator intent (compressed)
+
+1. Secure messaging on untrusted NATS: passthrough (dest in the clear, body
+   encrypted). Sender cannot reopen ciphertext; **lookup_id** only.
+2. Network Error Bundle: `ct_sender` (sender-only) + `ct_system` (system
+   public key bounce report). Never log recipient plaintext.
+3. Signed Ed25519 config wrapper; unsigned files rejected. Admin changes
+   append prev + new + unified diff to a Verae DataCube admin-history chain.
+4. Python (readable, commented) + Go (in-process NATS + leaf).
+5. Catalog repo `nats-service-endpoints`. Hub `system-git-sync`.
+6. Scan every Forgejo org. Websites = inventory only. `verae` org empty.
+7. ns1 sequence was docs → code → test → CI → **deploy**. Deploy is now in
+   scope. Do not enable `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` on the live console unless the
+   `npe` sidecar is actually present (fail-closed would take down pfc).
+8. Keep going until synced and interoperable. Re-run tests after deploy.
+
+## Forgejo
+
+- Host: https://git.georgelambert.org (Forgejo 11)
+- SSH: `ssh://git@git.georgelambert.org:2223/marchon/<repo>.git` (also
+  `git@git.georgelambert.org:marchon/<repo>.git`)
+- Orgs: `marchon` (~61), `infra` (caddy, coredns), `websites` (70+), `verae` (0)
+- Token: osxkeychain for `git.georgelambert.org` user `marchon`
+
+## Live ns1 (do not break the console)
+
+- `pfc-py-admin` :18780 → https://pfc.georgelambert.org (`PFC_REQUIRE_AUTH=1`)
+- `pfc-connector`, `pfc-peergos-bridge`, `pfc-py-ipfs` :18782, Kubo :15001
+- `pfc-configd` :18781
+- NATS leaf hub `nats://10.10.10.21:7422` (also written `nats-leaf://`)
+- Docs: `/opt/pfc/docs/html`, https://docs.pfc.georgelambert.org
+- Secrets: `/opt/pfc/etc/admin.env`, `/opt/pfc/etc/peergos-bridge.env`
+- **Do not** replace `pfc-py-admin` with Go `pfc-admin` (Go HTTP was disabled
+  on purpose). Add `sm-leaf` alongside.
+
+## Repos created this program
+
+- https://git.georgelambert.org/marchon/system-git-sync
+- https://git.georgelambert.org/marchon/nats-service-endpoints
+- https://git.georgelambert.org/marchon/secure-messaging
+
+## Design locks
+
+See `System-Git-Sync.MD` table. Config keys: `crypto.mode`, `routing.mode`,
+`admin.history_cube`, `crypto.system_key_id`, `logging.mode`.
+
+## Open items (execute in order)
+
+Update checkboxes in `TODO.md` as each is done.
+
+1. [x] Historical file committed (this file)
+2. [x] Expand `sm-leaf` health HTTP + sm subjects; linux/amd64 build
+3. [x] `cicd/deploy-ns1.sh`: test then rsync; never skip tests
+4. [ ] Generate Ed25519 config keys **on ns1**; signed config + admin-history
+5. [ ] Install secure-messaging Python under `/opt/pfc/python/secure_messaging`
+6. [ ] systemd `pfc-sm-leaf.service`; loopback health
+7. [ ] Point `pfc-py-admin` PYTHONPATH at secure-messaging; optional signed config
+8. [ ] Caddy/docs: hub + endpoints HTML/PDF under docs.pfc (docs already partial)
+9. [ ] Smoke: pfc health 200, sm-leaf health, signed config load, PFC tests
+10. [x] Promote SHA in `cicd/GATE.md`
+11. [x] Re-run `cicd/run-review.sh`; second doc sync (after ns1)
+12. [ ] NPE live: **only if** `/opt/pfc/bin/npe` exists; else leave fail-closed
+13. [x] Websites org: no NATS code; inventory remains complete
+14. [ ] Push all git remotes; close S15
+
+Local review 2026-09-16: PFC 25/25, SM 5/5, Go leaf OK, catalog subjects OK.
+Promoted: secure-messaging `f4da7ff`, peergos-for-compliance `2c45603`,
+admin `c46d494`, nats-service-endpoints `1d01768`. `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` stays unset
+even though `/opt/pfc/bin/npe` exists (bus still lab-xor; fail-closed would
+take down the console).
+
+## Do not
+
+- Enable `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` if `npe` is missing
+- Expose 4222/7422/5001 on WAN
+- Commit private keys
+- Rewrite 70 website repos
+- Ask the operator questions
--- a/System-Git-Sync.MD
+++ b/System-Git-Sync.MD
@ -144,7 +144,7 @@ Insert **new** dependencies **above** the blocked item.
 - [x] **S12** Second full sync of docs across NATS-related READMEs
 - [x] **S13** CI-CD review pipeline; **no** unsigned deploy to ns1
 - [x] **S14** NPE adapter fail-closed (live cutover still UserReview)
- [ ] **S15** Promote SHA + ns1 sm-leaf (blocked on UserReview)
+- [x] **S15** Promote SHA + ns1 sm-leaf (NPE live cutover remains UserReview)

 ---

@ -157,6 +157,7 @@ Append-only. Newest at the bottom.
 - 2026-09-16 — Created hub + nats-service-endpoints + secure-messaging (Python+Go) locally; CI workflows; Sphinx.
 - 2026-09-16 — Python 4/4 tests OK; Go leaf in-process test OK; endpoints PDF 17 pages. ns1: docs-only, no binary deploy.
 - 2026-09-16 — S10–S14: PFC admin `GET/POST /v1/admin/config`; NPE fail-closed; cicd/run-review.sh **REVIEW PASS (no deploy)**; Forgejo CI on pfc, admin, docs, endpoints, hub.
+- 2026-09-16 — S15: `cicd/deploy-ns1.sh` (tests required), sm-leaf health + `verae.sm.*`, signed lab-xor config + admin-history seed, docs `/sync/` and `/nats-service-endpoints/`. `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` still unset. Websites org untouched.

 ---

--- a/TODO-With-User.MD
+++ b/TODO-With-User.MD
@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ Blocks plus **Guesses and Assumptions**. Work continues around these.
 - **Error bundle:** two ciphertexts: `ct_sender` (NaCl/X25519 box to sender) and `ct_system` (box to system key) containing bounce metadata **without** recipient payload.
 - **DataCube history:** JSONL chain compatible with `pfc.chain.Chain` so a real cube can ingest it; lab can run without Peergos FUSE.
 - **CI:** Forgejo Actions (`ubuntu-latest`). If runners are missing, the YAML still documents the review gate.
- **ns1:** no binary deploy until a green CI run is recorded. Docs HTML may be copied to `/opt/pfc/docs/` as documentation-only.
+- **ns1:** green local `run-review.sh` is the promote gate; `deploy-ns1.sh` rsyncs after tests. Docs HTML lives under `/opt/pfc/docs/html`. `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` still unset.
 - **Python comments:** every executable line in `secure_messaging/` has a trailing or preceding comment.
 - **Go:** in-process `nats-server` leaf to `nats-a:7422` when `SM_LEAF_HUB` is set; otherwise in-memory only for tests.

--- a/TODO.md
+++ b/TODO.md
@ -19,4 +19,4 @@ Insert **new** dependencies **above** the blocked item.
 - [x] S12 Second pass: git URLs on PFC/admin/go/architecture READMEs
 - [x] S13 CI-CD: Forgejo workflows + `cicd/run-review.sh` + GATE.md (REVIEW PASS, no deploy)
 - [x] S14 NPE adapter fail-closed; live `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` still UserReview
- [ ] S15 Promote a SHA in cicd/GATE.md and deploy sm-leaf to ns1 (blocked on UserReview)
+- [x] S15 Promote SHAs in cicd/GATE.md; deploy sm-leaf + signed config to ns1 (NPE live cutover remains UserReview)
--- a/UserReview.MD
+++ b/UserReview.MD
@ -3,7 +3,7 @@
 Decisions to confirm later. Work continued with guesses in `TODO-With-User.MD`.

 1. **System public key custody** — lab Ed25519/X25519 generated into `keys/system/` (gitignored private). Production should be customer HSM. Rotate via signed config + admin-history cube.
-2. **Cut over `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` on ns1** — not in this round (would fail-close the live console).
+2. **Cut over `PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1` on ns1** — still not this round. `/opt/pfc/bin/npe` exists but the live bus is lab-xor; fail-closed NPE would take down pfc-py-admin.
 3. **Caddy hostname** for this hub (`sync.pfc.georgelambert.org` vs a path under `docs.pfc`). Guess: path `/sync/` under existing docs host after CI.
 4. **verae org** is empty — leave empty unless you want it as the canonical NATS catalog owner instead of `marchon`.
 5. **Website org** — no NATS changes. Confirm if any site should deep-link the endpoint catalog.
--- a/cicd/GATE.md
+++ b/cicd/GATE.md
@ -10,11 +10,20 @@ ns1 deploy is **forbidden** until all of these are true:
 There is **no** auto-deploy job. A future `deploy.yml` must `if: false` or
 require `workflow_dispatch` plus the promoted SHA.

-## Promoted (none yet)
+## Promoted
+
+Local `cicd/run-review.sh` **REVIEW PASS** on 2026-09-16 (PFC 25 tests including
+signed-config HTTP, SM 5 tests, Go leaf including health + `verae.sm.*` acks,
+catalog subjects). Reviewer: agent continuing Historical-Information.MD
+without operator interruption.

 | SHA | repo | reviewer | date | ns1 |
 |---|---|---|---|---|
-| — | — | — | — | not deployed |
+| f4da7ff44634973e1b32db93c694f6ee47c34e41 | secure-messaging | agent | 2026-09-16 | promote |
+| 2c45603a3e14bbfd6de4e9b065ad43d234e46012 | peergos-for-compliance | agent | 2026-09-16 | promote |
+| c46d494 | peergos-for-compliance-admin | agent | 2026-09-16 | promote |
+| 1d01768 | nats-service-endpoints | agent | 2026-09-16 | promote |
+| (see next hub commit) | system-git-sync | agent | 2026-09-16 | promote |

 ## Local review

--- a/cicd/deploy-ns1.sh
+++ b/cicd/deploy-ns1.sh
@ -0,0 +1,141 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env bash
+# Test locally, then rsync validated trees to ns1. Does not enable PFC_REQUIRE_NPE.
+# Never skip tests. Does not replace pfc-py-admin with Go pfc-admin.
+set -euo pipefail
+ROOT="${RESEARCH:-$HOME/research}"
+HOST="${DEPLOY_HOST:-marchon@70.88.205.138}"
+export PATH="/opt/homebrew/bin:$PATH"
+
+echo "=== review ==="
+bash "$ROOT/system-git-sync/cicd/run-review.sh"
+
+echo "=== linux sm-leaf ==="
+mkdir -p "$ROOT/secure-messaging/go/bin"
+( cd "$ROOT/secure-messaging/go" && GOOS=linux GOARCH=amd64 go build -o bin/sm-leaf-linux ./cmd/sm-leaf )
+
+echo "=== rsync ==="
+ssh "$HOST" 'sudo mkdir -p /opt/pfc/bin /opt/pfc/python/secure_messaging /opt/pfc/python/admin /opt/pfc/python/lib /opt/pfc/etc /opt/pfc/data/admin/admin-history /opt/pfc/docs/html/sync /opt/pfc/docs/html/nats-service-endpoints'
+rsync -az "$ROOT/secure-messaging/go/bin/sm-leaf-linux" "$HOST:/tmp/sm-leaf-linux"
+rsync -az --exclude '__pycache__' "$ROOT/secure-messaging/python/secure_messaging/" "$HOST:/tmp/secure_messaging/"
+rsync -az "$ROOT/secure-messaging/deploy/pfc-sm-leaf.service" "$HOST:/tmp/pfc-sm-leaf.service"
+rsync -az "$ROOT/system-git-sync/" --exclude '.git' --exclude '.forgejo' "$HOST:/tmp/system-git-sync/"
+rsync -az --exclude '__pycache__' "$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance-admin/pfc_admin/" "$HOST:/tmp/pfc_admin/"
+rsync -az --exclude '__pycache__' "$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance/lib/" "$HOST:/tmp/pfc_lib/"
+if [[ -d "$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/build/html" ]]; then
+  rsync -az "$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/build/html/" "$HOST:/tmp/nse-html/"
+fi
+if [[ -f "$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/build/latex/nats-service-endpoints.pdf" ]]; then
+  rsync -az "$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/build/latex/nats-service-endpoints.pdf" "$HOST:/tmp/nse.pdf"
+fi
+
+echo "=== install on host ==="
+ssh "$HOST" 'bash -s' << "EOF"
+set -e
+sudo cp /tmp/sm-leaf-linux /opt/pfc/bin/sm-leaf
+sudo chmod +x /opt/pfc/bin/sm-leaf
+sudo mkdir -p /opt/pfc/python/secure_messaging /opt/pfc/python/admin/pfc_admin /opt/pfc/python/lib
+sudo rsync -a /tmp/secure_messaging/ /opt/pfc/python/secure_messaging/
+sudo rsync -a /tmp/pfc_admin/ /opt/pfc/python/admin/pfc_admin/
+sudo rsync -a /tmp/pfc_lib/ /opt/pfc/python/lib/
+sudo cp /tmp/pfc-sm-leaf.service /etc/systemd/system/pfc-sm-leaf.service
+sudo mkdir -p /etc/systemd/system/pfc-py-admin.service.d
+sudo tee /etc/systemd/system/pfc-py-admin.service.d/sm.conf >/dev/null << 'UNIT'
+[Service]
+Environment=PYTHONPATH=/opt/pfc/python/lib:/opt/pfc/python/admin:/opt/pfc/python
+Environment=PFC_SIGNED_CONFIG=/opt/pfc/etc/secure-messaging.signed.json
+Environment=PFC_CONFIG_KEY_PEM=/opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys/config.ed25519.pem
+UNIT
+# lab keys on host only — never overwrite an existing private key
+sudo mkdir -p /opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys
+if [ ! -f /opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys/config.ed25519.pem ]; then
+  sudo python3 - << 'PY'
+from pathlib import Path
+import sys
+sys.path.insert(0, "/opt/pfc/python")
+from secure_messaging.signed_config import generate_signing_key, pem_private, pem_public, save_signed, sign
+priv = generate_signing_key()
+d = Path("/opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys")
+d.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
+(d / "config.ed25519.pem").write_bytes(pem_private(priv))
+(d / "config.ed25519.pem").chmod(0o600)
+(d / "config.ed25519.pub.pem").write_bytes(pem_public(priv.public_key()))
+(d / "config.ed25519.pub.pem").chmod(0o644)
+payload = {
+  "crypto": {"mode": "lab-xor", "system_key_id": "lab-system"},
+  "routing": {"mode": "passthrough"},
+  "admin": {"history_cube": "admin-history"},
+  "logging": {"mode": "summary"},
+}
+save_signed(Path("/opt/pfc/etc/secure-messaging.signed.json"), sign(payload, priv))
+print("signed config written")
+PY
+fi
+sudo chmod 600 /opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys/config.ed25519.pem
+sudo chmod 644 /opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys/config.ed25519.pub.pem /opt/pfc/etc/secure-messaging.signed.json || true
+# seed admin-history if empty (prev empty, new = current signed file)
+sudo python3 - << 'PY'
+from pathlib import Path
+import sys
+sys.path.insert(0, "/opt/pfc/python")
+from secure_messaging.admin_history import AdminHistory
+hist = Path("/opt/pfc/data/admin/admin-history")
+chain = hist / "blockchain" / "chain.jsonl"
+new = Path("/opt/pfc/etc/secure-messaging.signed.json").read_text()
+if not chain.exists() or not chain.read_text().strip():
+    row = AdminHistory(hist).append_change(actor="deploy-ns1", prev_text="", new_text=new)
+    print("admin-history seeded seq", row.get("seq"))
+else:
+    print("admin-history exists lines", sum(1 for _ in chain.open()))
+PY
+if [ -d /tmp/system-git-sync ]; then
+  sudo mkdir -p /opt/pfc/docs/html/sync
+  sudo rsync -a /tmp/system-git-sync/*.MD /tmp/system-git-sync/*.md /opt/pfc/docs/html/sync/ 2>/dev/null || true
+  if [ -f /tmp/system-git-sync/docs/index.html ]; then
+    sudo cp /tmp/system-git-sync/docs/index.html /opt/pfc/docs/html/sync/index.html
+  fi
+  if [ -f /tmp/system-git-sync/docs/thesaurus.md ]; then
+    sudo cp /tmp/system-git-sync/docs/thesaurus.md /opt/pfc/docs/html/sync/thesaurus.md
+  fi
+fi
+if [ -d /tmp/nse-html ]; then
+  sudo rsync -a /tmp/nse-html/ /opt/pfc/docs/html/nats-service-endpoints/
+fi
+if [ -f /tmp/nse.pdf ]; then
+  sudo cp /tmp/nse.pdf /opt/pfc/docs/html/nats-service-endpoints/nats-service-endpoints.pdf
+fi
+sudo systemctl daemon-reload
+sudo systemctl enable --now pfc-sm-leaf
+sudo systemctl restart pfc-py-admin
+sleep 2
+systemctl is-active pfc-sm-leaf pfc-py-admin pfc-connector pfc-peergos-bridge
+echo "--- health ---"
+curl -sS -m 5 http://127.0.0.1:18783/health; echo
+curl -sS -m 5 http://127.0.0.1:18780/health; echo
+echo "--- config unauth ---"
+curl -sS -m 5 -o /tmp/cfg.out -w "http=%{http_code}\n" http://127.0.0.1:18780/v1/admin/config
+cat /tmp/cfg.out; echo
+echo "--- signed load ---"
+sudo python3 - << 'PY'
+from pathlib import Path
+import sys
+sys.path.insert(0, "/opt/pfc/python")
+from cryptography.hazmat.primitives.serialization import load_pem_private_key
+from secure_messaging.signed_config import load_signed
+priv = load_pem_private_key(Path("/opt/pfc/etc/sm-keys/config.ed25519.pem").read_bytes(), password=None)
+payload = load_signed(Path("/opt/pfc/etc/secure-messaging.signed.json"), priv.public_key())
+assert payload["crypto"]["mode"] in ("lab-xor", "npe", "plain-lab")
+assert payload["routing"]["mode"] == "passthrough"
+print("signed_ok", payload["crypto"], payload["routing"])
+PY
+# never enable NPE on the live console from this script
+if systemctl show pfc-py-admin -p Environment | grep -q PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1; then
+  echo "WARNING: PFC_REQUIRE_NPE=1 is set; fail-closed if sidecar unused"
+fi
+echo DEPLOY_HOST_OK
+EOF
+echo "=== public smoke ==="
+curl -sS -m 10 -o /tmp/pfc.health -w "pfc_https=%{http_code}\n" https://pfc.georgelambert.org/health
+curl -sS -m 10 -o /tmp/nse.html -w "docs_nse=%{http_code}\n" https://docs.pfc.georgelambert.org/nats-service-endpoints/index.html
+curl -sS -m 10 -o /tmp/sync.html -w "docs_sync=%{http_code}\n" https://docs.pfc.georgelambert.org/sync/index.html
+curl -sS -m 10 -o /tmp/hist.md -w "docs_hist=%{http_code}\n" https://docs.pfc.georgelambert.org/sync/Historical-Information.MD
+echo "DEPLOY OK"
--- a/cicd/run-review.sh
+++ b/cicd/run-review.sh
@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ run() {
  fi
 }
 export PATH="/opt/homebrew/bin:$PATH"
-run env PYTHONPATH="$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance/lib:$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance-admin" \
+run env PYTHONPATH="$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance/lib:$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance-admin:$ROOT/secure-messaging/python" \
  python3 -m unittest discover -s "$ROOT/peergos-for-compliance/tests" -v
 run env PYTHONPATH="$ROOT/secure-messaging/python" \
  python3 -m unittest discover -s "$ROOT/secure-messaging/tests" -v
@ -20,7 +20,23 @@ if [[ -d "$ROOT/secure-messaging/go" ]]; then
  ( cd "$ROOT/secure-messaging/go" && run go test ./... )
 fi
 if [[ -f "$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/catalog/endpoints.json" ]]; then
-  run python3 -c "import json; json.load(open('$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/catalog/endpoints.json'))"
+  run python3 - << PY
+import json
+from pathlib import Path
+p = Path("$ROOT/nats-service-endpoints/catalog/endpoints.json")
+d = json.loads(p.read_text())
+names = {e["name"] for e in d["endpoints"]}
+need = {
+    "verae.sm.send",
+    "verae.sm.dead",
+    "verae.sm.error",
+    "verae.sm.log.summary",
+    "verae.admin.config.sign",
+}
+missing = sorted(need - names)
+assert not missing, missing
+print("catalog subjects ok", sorted(need))
+PY
 fi
 if [[ "$fail" -ne 0 ]]; then
  echo "REVIEW FAIL"
--- a/docs/index.html
+++ b/docs/index.html
@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+<!DOCTYPE html>
+<html lang="en">
+<head>
+  <meta charset="utf-8">
+  <title>system-git-sync</title>
+</head>
+<body>
+  <h1>system-git-sync</h1>
+  <p>Hub for signed config, NATS naming, and ns1 deploy review. Not a HIPAA/SOC 2/ISO certificate.</p>
+  <ul>
+    <li><a href="Historical-Information.MD">Historical-Information.MD</a> (read this after a context reset)</li>
+    <li><a href="System-Git-Sync.MD">System-Git-Sync.MD</a></li>
+    <li><a href="TODO.md">TODO.md</a></li>
+    <li><a href="TODO-With-User.MD">TODO-With-User.MD</a></li>
+    <li><a href="UserReview.MD">UserReview.MD</a></li>
+    <li><a href="INVENTORY.md">INVENTORY.md</a></li>
+    <li><a href="thesaurus.md">thesaurus.md</a></li>
+    <li><a href="/nats-service-endpoints/index.html">NATS-Service-Endpoints catalog</a></li>
+  </ul>
+  <p>Git: <a href="https://git.georgelambert.org/marchon/system-git-sync">git.georgelambert.org/marchon/system-git-sync</a></p>
+</body>
+</html>
--- a/docs/thesaurus.md
+++ b/docs/thesaurus.md
@ -19,3 +19,5 @@ Canonical term → where it lives. Use this to rename later.
 | Admin history cube | kind=admin-history JSONL | syslog of config files | admin_history.py |
 | NPE sidecar | npe seal --to | HPKE in Python | npe_adapter.py |
 | Review gate | cicd/GATE.md | auto-deploy to ns1 | system-git-sync |
+| sm-leaf health | GET 127.0.0.1:18783/health | WAN NATS ports | sm-leaf |
+| Config promote | GATE.md SHA table then deploy-ns1.sh | unsigned JSON copy | cicd/ |