Closes #23. ## What Adds the missing normative requirement that a Server Card's declared values must not contradict the server's actual runtime behavior. The schema already encodes the *omission* half of the threat model (primitives are deliberately excluded because a static manifest drifts from runtime); this adds the *complementary* requirement for the fields the card **does** declare. ### `docs/discovery.md` - **New "Consistency with Runtime Behavior" subsection** under "MCP Server Cards": - A Server Card SHOULD accurately reflect the server's actual runtime behavior. The `serverInfo` (`name`, `version`) and `supportedVersions` returned by [`server/discover`](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/draft/server/discover), plus the transport actually served at each `remotes[]` endpoint (and descriptive `title`/`description`/`icons`), SHOULD NOT contradict the equivalent values declared in the Server Card. - Clients MUST NOT treat Server Card contents as authoritative for security or access-control decisions, and SHOULD verify claims against the live connection — the same posture the spec takes toward primitives, generalized to the declared fields. - **New "Server Card Accuracy" subsection** under "Security Considerations": frames an inaccurate (stale or crafted) card as a mild confusion/downgrade vector, so the consistency requirement is partly a security property, not just correctness. It is explanatory and points back to the single normative statement above rather than re-asserting the MUST NOT. ### `schema.ts` - Short pointer comment in the `ServerCard` JSDoc referencing the discovery-doc requirement, complementing the existing primitives-omission rationale. `schema.json` regenerated via `npm run generate` in the same commit (CI `check` enforces sync). RFC 2119 keywords are used consistently with the rest of `docs/discovery.md`. The runtime reference is phrased around the draft spec's [`server/discover`](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/draft/server/discover) operation — the pre-`initialize` exchange that actually returns `serverInfo`/`supportedVersions` — rather than SEP-2127's `DiscoverResultResponse`, which has no term in this repo. ## Security rationale Because a Server Card is consumed *before* the client connects, an inaccurate card can steer a client toward a weaker configuration (downgrade) or a misidentified server (confusion) before it has observed the server's actual `server/discover` response. Treating the card as advisory rather than authoritative contains this risk. ## Scope Small and focused strictly on the card-vs-runtime consistency requirement. Distinct from #10 (the inverse — primitives the card omits) and #13/#9/#11/#12/#14/#21 (none touch card-vs-runtime consistency). No unrelated changes. ## Verification - [x] `npm run check` passes — `schema.json` is in sync with `schema.ts` and `tsc --noEmit` is clean - [x] `npm run validate` passes — all 7 examples validate against the regenerated schema - [x] `npm run format` clean — no formatting changes left - [x] `schema.json` regenerated and committed alongside the `schema.ts` change (CI `check` enforces this) - [x] Fresh-eyes review by a separate agent — feedback addressed (full-term "Server Card" wording for consistency with the rest of the doc; de-duplicated the MUST NOT so the security section is explanatory and points to the single normative statement) - [x] Maintainer review (Sam) — substance approved; applied the requested brevity pass, tightening both new subsections with no change to any normative statement - [x] `server/discover` spec link verified to resolve to a real draft-spec page documenting `serverInfo` / `supportedVersions` - [x] CI green on the final commit (`0d0389b`) — build, Analyze (actions), and CodeQL all pass This is a docs/comment-only change (no runtime code paths), so the verification is the build/schema toolchain rather than e2e tests. Local toolchain output: ``` ✓ Generated schema.json ✓ schema.json is up to date (npm run check) All 7 example(s) passed. (npm run validate) ``` Opened for human review — **not** merged, per repo policy. --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
13 KiB
Discovery
Protocol Revision: draft
MCP defines a discovery mechanism that enables clients to find available MCP servers on a domain without prior configuration. This mechanism complements the lifecycle handshake by answering where to connect, before the protocol establishes how to communicate.
MCP Catalog
An MCP Catalog is a JSON document published by an organization to advertise the MCP Server Cards relevant to its services.
The catalog MAY reference servers on different domains than the catalog itself — for
example, acme.org/.well-known/... MAY advertise servers operated by
mcp-server-host-saas.com on Acme's behalf. Clients can fetch this document to discover
servers and then retrieve individual Server Cards for connection
details.
The MCP Catalog format is a minimal, MCP-scoped subset of the AI Catalog specification. This alignment ensures that MCP Catalog entries can be used as-is within a full AI Catalog document, enabling a smooth migration path when the cross-protocol AI Catalog standard is finalized.
Well-Known URI
Organizations offering services accessible via MCP SHOULD publish an MCP Catalog at the domain users associate with the service. The MCP Catalog should live at:
/.well-known/mcp/catalog.json
This endpoint:
- MUST be accessible via HTTPS (HTTP MAY be supported for local/development use)
- MUST include appropriate CORS headers (see CORS Requirements)
- SHOULD include appropriate caching headers (see Caching)
Catalog Format
An MCP Catalog document is a JSON object that MUST contain the following members:
| Member | Type | Required | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
specVersion |
string | Yes | The version of the MCP Catalog format (currently "draft") |
entries |
array | Yes | An array of Catalog Entry objects. This array MAY be empty. |
Catalog Entry
Each entry in the entries array describes a single MCP server and MUST contain:
| Member | Type | Required | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
identifier |
string | Yes | A URN identifying this server (e.g., urn:mcp:server:com.example/weather) |
displayName |
string | Yes | A human-readable name for the server |
mediaType |
string | Yes | The media type of the referenced artifact. MUST be application/mcp-server-card+json |
url |
string | Yes | URL where the full Server Card can be retrieved |
The identifier MUST begin with urn:mcp:server: and end with the name value of the
referenced Server Card, with no characters in between.
Example: Single Server
A domain hosting a single MCP server, using only the required fields:
{
"specVersion": "draft",
"entries": [
{
"identifier": "urn:mcp:server:com.example/weather",
"displayName": "Weather Service",
"mediaType": "application/mcp-server-card+json",
"url": "https://example.com/mcp/server-card"
}
]
}
Example: Multiple Servers
A domain hosting several MCP servers, each with its own server card:
{
"specVersion": "draft",
"entries": [
{
"identifier": "urn:mcp:server:com.acme/code-review",
"displayName": "Code Review Assistant",
"mediaType": "application/mcp-server-card+json",
"url": "https://acme.com/code-review/server-card"
},
{
"identifier": "urn:mcp:server:com.acme/docs-search",
"displayName": "Documentation Search",
"mediaType": "application/mcp-server-card+json",
"url": "https://acme.com/docs-search/server-card"
},
{
"identifier": "urn:mcp:server:com.acme/ci-cd",
"displayName": "CI/CD Pipeline",
"mediaType": "application/mcp-server-card+json",
"url": "https://acme.com/ci-cd/server-card"
}
]
}
Client Discovery Flow
Clients performing domain-level discovery SHOULD follow this procedure:
flowchart TD
A[Client wants to discover MCP servers on example.com] --> B[Fetch /.well-known/mcp/catalog.json]
B --> C{Valid catalog returned?}
C -->|Yes| D[Parse entries array]
C -->|No| E[Discovery unavailable for this domain]
D --> F[For each entry, fetch server card from url]
F --> G[Use server card to configure connection]
- Fetch
https://{domain}/.well-known/mcp/catalog.json - If a valid MCP Catalog is returned, iterate over the
entriesarray - For each entry, retrieve the server card from the entry's
url, expressing the Server Card media type via theAcceptheader (see Server Card Location) - Use the server card metadata to configure and establish an MCP connection
Clients SHOULD validate that each entry has mediaType set to application/mcp-server-card+json
and ignore entries with unrecognized media types.
MCP Server Cards
An MCP Server Card is a JSON document that describes a single MCP server — its
identity and connection details. Server Cards use the media type
application/mcp-server-card+json.
Server Cards do not enumerate primitives (tools, resources, prompts); those remain subject to runtime listing via the protocol's standard list operations.
A Server Card includes:
name— A unique identifier for the server in reverse DNS format (e.g.,com.example/weather)- Connection details — Transport type and endpoint URL
- Metadata — Human-readable name, description, and version
For the full Server Card specification, see SEP-2127: MCP Server Cards.
Consistency with Runtime Behavior
A Server Card is fetched before the client connects, so its contents are unverified when
read. A Server Card SHOULD accurately reflect the server's runtime behavior: the values a
client observes once connected — the serverInfo (name, version) and supportedVersions
from server/discover,
the transport served at each remotes[] endpoint, and descriptive fields (title,
description, icons) — SHOULD NOT contradict the equivalent values declared in the Server
Card.
As with the deliberately omitted primitives (tools, resources, prompts), a static manifest can drift from runtime, so even the fields a Server Card does declare are advisory rather than binding. Accordingly:
- Clients MUST NOT treat Server Card contents as authoritative for security or access-control decisions.
- Clients SHOULD verify a Server Card's claims against the live connection, preferring the runtime values where the two disagree.
Server Card Location
The Catalog is the discovery entrypoint, and every Catalog Entry already carries the
url where its Server Card can be retrieved. Clients therefore never need to guess a
Server Card's location — they follow the url the Catalog gives them. As a result, a
Server Card MAY be hosted at any unreserved URI.
To give servers a predictable default, MCP reserves one location:
MCP Servers MAY host their Server Card at
GET <streamable-http-url>/server-card, which we reserve for this purpose, though any unreserved URI (on any domain) is valid. MCP Servers SHOULD respect theapplication/mcp-server-card+jsonmedia type wherever they choose to host it. After a client identifies a Server Card URL from an AI Catalog or MCP Catalog, it SHOULD request that URL expressing theapplication/mcp-server-card+jsonmedia type.
Concretely:
- A client requesting a Server Card SHOULD send
Accept: application/mcp-server-card+jsonon the GET request. (Acceptis the representation-negotiation header for a GET; the server echoes the negotiated type back in the responseContent-Type.) - The
/server-cardsuffix is appended to the server's streamable-HTTP URL, not to the domain root. A server that lives athttps://host/mcptherefore naturally yieldshttps://host/mcp/server-card— you get path-namespacing for free without inventing a separate convention.
Alternatives considered
The following placements were considered and not recommended:
- A
.well-knownURI (e.g.,/.well-known/mcp/server-card)..well-knownis for site-wide metadata, whereas an individual server's card is application-level metadata. Because the Catalog is the discovery entrypoint and already provides each card'surl, hosting the card under.well-knownadds no value — the card can live anywhere the Catalog points. (Note:.well-knownremains correct for the Catalog itself at/.well-known/mcp/catalog.jsonand for OAuth metadata such as/.well-known/oauth-protected-resource— those are genuinely site-wide. This change applies only to the single-server Server Card.) - The bare streamable-HTTP endpoint (
GET <streamable-http-url>with no suffix). In the Streamable HTTP transport aGETon the MCP endpoint already has a reserved meaning — it opens the SSE stream. Serving the card there overloads that endpoint and forces content negotiation to disambiguate "give me the card" from "open the stream." This remains spec-allowed (any unreserved URI is valid) but is explicitly not recommended; avoiding the overload of the connection-establishing endpoint is the primary motivation for reserving a distinct/server-cardsuffix. - Nesting under a domain-root
/mcp/(e.g.,/mcp/server-card). In MCP,/mcpdenotes the transport endpoint itself (canonical-URI examples:https://mcp.example.com/mcp,https://mcp.example.com/server/mcp). There is no precedent for/mcp/as a metadata sub-namespace relative to a server URL. Nesting under/mcp/collides conceptually with "the JSON-RPC endpoint" and creates ambiguity about whether the path is relative to the server URL or the domain root. (This is distinct from a server that simply happens to live athttps://host/mcp: there,https://host/mcp/server-cardis just<streamable-http-url>+/server-card— the recommended convention — not a domain-root/mcp/metadata namespace.)
Relationship to AI Catalog
The MCP Catalog is designed as a transitional mechanism. The
AI Catalog specification defines a
cross-protocol discovery standard (/.well-known/ai-catalog.json) capable of indexing
MCP servers, A2A agents, and other AI artifacts.
MCP Catalog entries are structurally compatible with AI Catalog entries. When the AI Catalog standard is finalized and adopted by the MCP steering committee:
- Domains MAY serve both
/.well-known/mcp/catalog.jsonand/.well-known/ai-catalog.jsonduring a transition period - MCP Catalog entries can be included directly in an AI Catalog document without modification
- Domains that want richer metadata (trust manifests, publisher identity, collections) can adopt the full AI Catalog format
Security Considerations
Information Disclosure
MCP Catalogs are publicly accessible by design. Catalog entries MUST NOT include sensitive information such as:
- Authentication credentials or tokens
- Internal network topology or private endpoints
- Proprietary business logic
Server Card Accuracy
A Server Card is consumed before the client connects, so an inaccurate one — stale or
deliberately crafted — is a mild confusion or downgrade vector: one that overstates
transport or protocol-version support, or misrepresents the server's identity, can steer a
client toward a weaker configuration or the wrong server before it observes the actual
server/discover response. This makes the consistency requirement partly a security
property, not merely a matter of correctness. The normative protections live in
Consistency with Runtime Behavior: clients do not
treat a Server Card as authoritative and reconcile it against the live connection.
CORS Requirements
Discovery endpoints MUST include appropriate CORS headers to allow browser-based clients:
Access-Control-Allow-Origin: *
Access-Control-Allow-Methods: GET
Access-Control-Allow-Headers: Content-Type
This is safe because MCP Catalogs contain only public metadata and are read-only.
Caching
Servers SHOULD include caching headers to reduce unnecessary requests:
Cache-Control: public, max-age=3600
Transport Security
MCP Catalogs MUST be served over HTTPS (TLS 1.2 or later) in production. HTTP MAY be used for local development only.
Denial of Service
MCP Servers SHOULD implement rate limiting on their Server Card endpoint to prevent abuse.
MCP Clients SHOULD respect Cache-Control headers and avoid unnecessary polling.