transports-wg/meetings/2026-01-28_weekly.md
Kurtis Van Gent 1de2540eb3
feat: add 2026-01-28 weekly meeting notes (#10)
add 2026-01-28 weekly meeting notes
2026-02-03 16:05:53 -08:00

4.6 KiB

2026-01-28 Transports WG (Weekly)

TL;DR

The group discussed updates on the Python SDK refactoring, noting a "holding pattern" while waiting for a PR from Google's Powan. Shaun Smith confirmed the submission of a Specification Enhancement Proposal (SEP) to formally deprecate unsolicited sampling and elicitation on the background channel. The primary focus was reconciling the Multi-Round Trip Request (MRTR) proposal with the "Tasks" mechanism. The group agreed that the "get stream" (SSE) must be optional for core functionality like elicitation. A technical debate regarding data structures (Map vs. Array) for server-initiated requests led to a decision to split the work into two parallel, consistent proposals—one for the ephemeral case (led by Mark Roth) and one for the persistent case (led by Caitie McCaffrey)—to be reviewed after an offline sync.

Detailed Summary

SDKs and Process

  • Python SDK Refactoring: Kryspin Ziemski and Mark Roth discussed the status of the Python SDK. The group is waiting for a Pull Request from Powan regarding the separation of server and runner before pushing further changes.
  • Verscell Integration: Kryspin Ziemski asked about contacts at Verscell regarding their custom MCP implementation. Shaun Smith confirmed he is in touch with Matt Lenhard and offered to connect them offline.
  • Unsolicited Requests SEP: Shaun Smith submitted the SEP discussed the previous week to formally deprecate unsolicited sampling and elicitation on the background "get stream."
  • Data Usage: Shaun Smith offered to share data from "several million sessions" of MCP usage scraped from his server to assist with decision-making.

Technical Decisions: MRTR and Tasks

  • Optionality of SSE Streams: Caitie McCaffrey argued that to ensure the protocol works in stateless environments like Cloud Run, the "get stream" (SSE) must not be required for core functionality like elicitation and sampling. The group agreed to scope this change to elicitation/sampling first, deferring progress notifications.
  • Ephemeral vs. Persistent Flows:
    • Tool Calls (Ephemeral): Defined as short-running, synchronous, and stateless. Mark Roth proposed a flow where the server returns an incomplete response, and the client retries with the original info plus the response.
    • Tasks (Persistent): Defined as long-running, asynchronous, and stateful. Caitie McCaffrey and Luca Chang clarified the "Input Required" state, where the client polls for a result and receives an elicitation request.
  • Message Structure Alignment:
    • Mark Roth argued for using consistent message types for the "elicitation response" in both ephemeral and persistent cases.
    • Map vs. Array: A debate arose regarding the container for server-initiated requests. Mark Roth proposed a Map structure (key-value) to handle multiple parallel requests and ensure association if server logic changes. Caitie McCaffrey and Luca Chang pushed back, suggesting this introduces ambiguity and complexity, preferring arrays or reusing existing ToolResult structures.
  • Unique Keys: The group debated the necessity of unique keys for server requests within a single tool call context. Mark Roth argued they are needed for association; Caitie McCaffrey suggested parameter names might be sufficient.

Path Forward

  • Dual Proposals: To resolve the complexity, the group decided to split the work into two parallel proposals that will be kept consistent:
    1. Ephemeral Case: Led by Mark Roth, focusing on the stateless request/response flow without tasks.
    2. Persistent Case: Led by Caitie McCaffrey, focusing on how Tasks utilize the request/response flow for stateful operations.
  • Synchronization: Mark Roth, Caitie McCaffrey, and Luca Chang will meet offline to align on data structures before the next meeting.

Action Items

  • Shaun Smith to connect with Kryspin Ziemski offline regarding Matt Lenhard and Verscell.
  • Mark Roth to update the track brief to explicitly call out the agreed goals (making SSE optional).
  • Mark Roth to schedule an offline sync with Caitie McCaffrey and Luca Chang for Friday to resolve data structure nuances (Map vs. Array).
  • Mark Roth to update the Ephemeral MRTR proposal to explicitly cover single back-and-forth, multiple back-and-forth, and multiple requests in a single response.
  • Caitie McCaffrey to update the Persistent/Tasks proposal to align with the ephemeral definitions.