transports-wg/meetings/2026-02-25_weekly.md
2026-03-12 13:09:24 -06:00

4.3 KiB

2026-02-25 Transports WG (Weekly)

TL;DR

The working group agreed to advance the Multi-Roundtrip Request (MRTR) Specification Enhancement Proposal (SEP) to the core contributors for initial feedback, despite open questions regarding SDK backward compatibility. To manage the SEP's complexity, the group decided to decouple a significant redesign of the Tasks API from the current proposal. Caitie McCaffrey will formalize the schema changes, which treat requests for more information as optional parameters to gracefully handle client mismatches. Additionally, Shaun Smith presented an early draft for Session management. The group discussed open design questions regarding server identity, Key-Value store usage, and handling servers that mix stateful and stateless tools, culminating in an action item for Shaun Smith to draft a formal SEP detailing these specific use cases.

Detailed Summary

MRTR SEP: Error Handling & Mismatched Inputs

  • Caitie McCaffrey submitted a PR to address error handling, proposing that servers treat requests for more information as optional parameters.
  • If a client returns unexpected or mismatched data (e.g., returning only one of two requested parameters), the server should simply ignore the unexpected data and re-request the missing information.
  • The group agreed this should be framed as guidance for tool developers rather than strict protocol-level error handling.
  • Concerns about infinite loops from clients repeatedly sending bad data should be handled via standard rate limiting and throttling, not at the protocol level.

MRTR SEP: Persistent Workflow & Tasks API

  • Luca Chang and Mark Roth discussed simplifying the persistent workflow by combining task status, input responses, and final results into a single unified tasks continue RPC.
  • However, to prevent the MRTR SEP from becoming overly bloated, the group reached a consensus to decouple this larger Tasks API redesign from the current MRTR proposal.
  • The group will proceed with the current MRTR structures and signal to SDK maintainers that the Tasks API remains experimental and subject to future optimization.

SEP Advancements & Core Contributor Review

  • Despite concerns raised by Shaun Smith and Peter Alexander regarding SDK backward compatibility and the lack of a live reference implementation, the group voted (7 approvals, 2 abstentions) to advance the MRTR SEP to the core maintainers to gather early feedback.
  • Caitie McCaffrey, Mark Roth, and Gabriel Zimmerman will finalize the schema changes by Friday to prepare for this review.
  • The separate Request-Response Association SEP was confirmed as accepted, and Caitie McCaffrey will proceed with merging it into the main repository.

Sessions Proposal (V2)

  • Shaun Smith demonstrated a rough draft PR for session management, utilizing the meta tag for cookie data to enable features like session creation, resumption, and deletion.
  • Open questions remain regarding server identity, the inclusion of a Key-Value (KV) store within the session data, and whether to include list/recover operations.
  • Caitie McCaffrey raised a critical scoping concern regarding the complexity of mixing stateful (session-based) and stateless tools within a single MCP server, suggesting that servers should ideally operate entirely in one paradigm or the other.
  • Kurtis Van Gent tasked Shaun Smith with drafting a concrete SEP that explicitly compares the approach to HTTP cookies and outlines the specific use cases and flows for session support.

Action Items

  • Caitie McCaffrey to format the error handling PR as guidance for tool developers rather than a strict protocol-level error handling mechanic.
  • Caitie McCaffrey, Mark Roth, and Gabriel Zimmerman to finalize and publish the proper set of schema changes for the MRTR SEP by Friday.
  • Caitie McCaffrey to ping Dan to confirm the merge of the Request-Response Association SEP.
  • Kurtis Van Gent to request time in the upcoming core contributors meeting for the MRTR SEP, send the relevant links, and ensure Mark Roth is added to the invite to discuss rationale.
  • Shaun Smith to draft a concrete SEP for Sessions that covers use cases, a comparison to HTTP cookies, and the flow/overlap for MCP servers mixing session and non-session support.