4.9 KiB
2026-03-11 Transports WG (Weekly)
TL;DR
The meeting centered on two major protocol design topics: the schema scope for Multi-Round Tool Results (MRTR) and a proposal to eliminate Data Layer Sessions entirely. Regarding MRTR, the group debated whether incomplete response features should be generic (applicable to all requests) or scoped only to specific contexts like tool calls. The consensus favored a generic approach, acknowledging the trade-off in SDK complexity, though the question will be escalated to David (DSP) for final guidance. The second major discussion involved Peter Alexander's "anti-sessions" proposal, which advocates for replacing formal protocol sessions with application-specific IDs passed within tool calls. This model-maximalist approach gained surprising traction among attendees for its simplicity and flexibility. The group agreed to draft a formal SEP for this sessionless approach and present both options (sessions vs. no sessions) to the core maintainers for early feedback.
Detailed Summary
MRTR Schema Design: Generic vs. Scoped Features
- The Dilemma: Caitie McCaffrey opened the discussion on whether MRTR
features (like
request stateandincomplete response data) should be added to the generic result object (applying to all requests) or scoped strictly to specific requests (like tool calls). - Arguments for Scoping: Mark Roth argued that allowing incomplete responses
on requests where they logically don't make sense (e.g.,
pingortask/get) forces all clients to handle edge cases unnecessarily. If the protocol allows it, clients must support it. - Arguments for Genericity: Luca Chang and Caitie McCaffrey countered that special-casing features introduces bugs and limits future innovation. Mike Kistler (speaking for SDK maintainers) noted that a generic implementation at the lower layers of the SDK is actually simpler to build.
- Consensus & Escalation: Caitie McCaffrey will draft a summary of the options and escalate the question to David (DSP) for a final ruling based on protocol design principles.
The "Anti-Sessions" Proposal
- The Pitch: Peter Alexander presented an argument to eliminate Data Layer
Sessions from the MCP protocol entirely. Instead of
session create/destroymechanics, applications would use specific tool calls (e.g.,create_shopping_cart) to generate application-specific IDs, which the model would then pass into subsequent tool calls. - Benefits: This approach simplifies the protocol, removes the overhead of session lifecycle management for lightweight sub-agents, and provides greater flexibility (e.g., sharing a single "basket ID" across multiple sub-agents or having multiple active state objects at once).
- The "Model Maximalist" View: Caitie McCaffrey and Kurtis Van Gent raised concerns about whether cheaper or open-source LLMs could reliably handle passing these IDs. Peter Alexander argued from a "model maximalist" perspective, stating that models are increasingly proficient at instruction following and variable tracking.
- Support: Mark Roth, Mike Kistler, and Geoff Goodman expressed strong support for the proposal, agreeing that sessions are often confusing and that leveraging existing tool call mechanisms is more elegant and scalable.
- Backward Compatibility: While acknowledging this is a major breaking change, the group agreed that removing unnecessary complexity now is preferable to maintaining a flawed feature.
Next Steps & Timeline
- Drafting the SEP: Peter Alexander will write a formal SEP for the sessionless proposal by the end of the week.
- Core Maintainer Review: Because the core maintainer meeting precedes the next Transports WG meeting, the group will vote asynchronously on Peter's draft. Both the original sessions proposal (by Shaun Smith) and the anti-sessions proposal will be presented to the core maintainers as an "early preview" to build consensus before Dev Days.
- Luca's Roadmap: Luca Chang is out for two weeks. Kurtis Van Gent will ensure Luca's priority task-related SEPs ("jump scares" and "task continue") are surfaced at the next core maintainer meeting.
Action Items
- Caitie McCaffrey to draft a summary of the generic vs. scoped MRTR options and escalate to David (DSP) via Discord for guidance.
- Peter Alexander to write a formal SEP detailing the proposal to remove sessions from the MCP protocol.
- Kurtis Van Gent to follow up with Shaun Smith to ensure the original sessions SEP is ready to serve as a counter-argument to the anti-sessions proposal.
- Caitie McCaffrey to initiate an asynchronous thread for the WG to review and vote on the two session proposals before the core maintainer meeting.
- Kurtis Van Gent to follow up with Luca Chang regarding the priority task-related SEPs before Luca's leave.