transports-wg/meetings/2026-02-11_weekly.md
2026-02-25 16:34:08 -07:00

4.1 KiB

2026-02-11 Transports WG (Weekly)

TL;DR

The meeting, facilitated by Mark Roth, focused on reviewing three in-flight Specification Enhancement Proposals (SEPs) to prepare them for the core maintainers. The group approved Shaun Smith's SEP to disallow unsolicited server-to-client requests, pending a clear definition of "associated" requests. Mike Kistler's HTTP Standardization SEP was also approved with modifications, specifically making schema validation optional for custom parameters on intermediate servers. Lastly, Luca Chang's Task Progress SEP faced pushback regarding the deprecation of SSE progress notifications; the group agreed to amend the SEP to add progress capabilities to tasks without removing the existing SSE mechanism, but will review the revised proposal again next week before advancing it.

Detailed Summary

Process & General Updates

  • Facilitation: Mark Roth facilitated the meeting as Kurtis Van Gent was driving.
  • Agent Contexts: Kryspin Ziemski briefly shared concepts for agents utilizing dynamic resources and stateful code modes to predict cause and effect.
  • MRTR Next Steps: Mark Roth will meet with Caitie McCaffrey and Gabriel Zimmerman on Friday to resolve open questions on the Multi-Round Trip Request (MRTR) proposal.

Technical Decisions: Sampling & Elicitation SEP

  • Scope & Ambiguity: Shaun Smith presented an SEP to clarify that server-initiated requests (like sampling and elicitation) cannot be unsolicited. Mike Kistler clarified that this applies to all server-initiated requests, not just sampling and elicitation.
  • Defining Association: Debate arose over how to associate server requests with client requests, especially for the standard IO transport. The group agreed to explicitly define "associated" in the SEP, meaning the server request must supply a matching JSON RPC request ID from the client.
  • Decision: The SEP was approved with changes to advance to the core maintainers. Shaun Smith will update the wording and coordinate with Mike Kistler.

Technical Decisions: HTTP Standardization SEP

  • Validation Requirements: Mike Kistler's SEP regarding HTTP headers was reviewed. The primary debate focused on whether intermediate servers (like load balancers) cracking the payload must validate custom headers against schemas they might not have access to.
  • Decision: The group agreed that if a server modifies or processes the payload, it must validate standard parameters. However, validating custom parameters is optional if the server lacks the schema; it can simply pass them along. The SEP was approved with these changes, and Kurtis Van Gent agreed to sponsor it.

Technical Decisions: Task Progress SEP

  • Deprecating SSE: Luca Chang presented an SEP to move progress notifications to the Tasks API and deprecate the current SSE-based progress mechanism.
  • Pushback: Significant objections came from Shaun Smith, Stephen Halter, and Simon Russell. They argued that removing SSE progress notifications breaks low-stakes, real-time use cases (e.g., multimodal inference, sub-agents, streaming results) where setting up a persistent Task is too heavyweight.
  • Decision: Mark Roth proposed modifying the SEP to only add progress notifications to tasks, abandoning the removal of the old SSE mechanism for now. Luca agreed. Caitie McCaffrey requested to review this revised proposal next week before it goes to the core maintainers.

Action Items

  • Shaun Smith to update the Sampling/Elicitation SEP with the agreed definition of "associated", sync with Mike Kistler, and move the PR to the main repo by Friday.
  • Mike Kistler to address comments on the HTTP Standardization PR, update the validation rules for custom parameters, and move the PR to the main repo by Friday.
  • Luca Chang to update the Task Progress SEP by Friday to only add progress to tasks without removing the old SSE mechanism.
  • Group to review Luca's updated Task Progress SEP asynchronously on Monday and Tuesday.
  • Mark Roth to add the revised Task Progress SEP and the MRTR proposal to next week's agenda.